Insights & Perspectives

Thoughts and observations from Kainoa

Staying Is Also a Career Decision

As a recruiter, people often assume that my goal is to convince candidates to change companies.

The reality is a little different.

Sometimes, the best career advice I can give is: stay where you are.

About 18 months ago, a candidate reached out to me after taking on a new internal role. The position itself was exciting and offered new challenges, but his relationship with his supervisor had become very strained.

After fifteen years with the company, he suddenly felt frustrated with everything and wanted to leave.

Ironically, he was a strong fit for several positions I was supporting at the time.

But as we talked, it became clear that he was making a decision from a position of disappointment rather than long-term career planning.

He had enjoyed his career up to that point. He liked the people he worked with. He believed in the products.

His problem was not necessarily the company. It was the situation.

My advice was simple. Take a step back. Look for solutions internally. Speak with senior management. Don’t assume that changing companies is the only solution.

A couple of days later, he contacted me again. His company had listened to his concerns and offered him an opportunity to transfer to another business unit.

About a year later, he reached out once more. Things were going well, and he was happy he had stayed.

I see the opposite side of this situation almost every day as well.

When I reach out to candidates, I often feel strongly that the opportunities I am introducing could have a positive impact on their careers.

But as I ask about their current situation, I hear things like:

“My children are still in grade school, and my company’s flexible schedule lets me spend time with my family.”

“I’m part of an internal training program, and I want to make the most of it.”

“I have a great relationship with my manager and team.”

“I like the people I work with, and the company is investing in my development.”

Quite often, my advice is exactly the same. Stay. You sound happy. You are growing. There is no reason to move simply because an opportunity exists. Let’s stay in touch, and I’ll call you again in six months.

One thing I have learned over the years is that people sometimes evaluate only the opportunities available in the market. But your current position is also an opportunity. It may offer strong career development, supportive leadership, work-life balance, flexibility for your family, internal mobility, or long-term stability. These things have real value.

This does not mean you should never change companies. Sometimes a move is exactly the right decision.

But staying should be an active decision, not simply the absence of one. Likewise, changing companies should be based on long-term goals, not short-term frustration.

The next time you hear about an interesting opportunity in the market, take a moment to evaluate something else as well.

Is your current situation already giving you what you are looking for?

Because sometimes, the right career move is not moving at all.

 

Recent Posts

Should Your Next Role Stretch You?

One of the recurring challenges I face in recruitment is this: Clients...

When Should You Ask for an Offer Extension?

This can be a sensitive question. But the direct answer is simple....

What Will Your Job Look Like One Year From Now?

It’s a simple idea, but one I picked up from Lou Adler...